Monday, August 10, 2026
Every Cloud Has a Silver Lining: Seeing the Light in the Darkest Moments of Jewish History
By Ken Spiro
Now that we have gotten past the darkest day in the Jewish calendar, the Ninth of Av, it's worth looking at a very interesting statement made by the rabbis in Midrash Eicha Rabbah 1:51, the rabbinic commentary on the Book of Lamentations, written by the prophet Jeremiah prior to the destruction of the First Temple 2,500 years ago, and the book traditionally read on the Ninth of Av. The Ninth of Av marks the date in the book of Numbers, Chapter 13, when the spies brought back their slanderous report about the Land of Israel, and since that event, it has become a magnet for so many of the worst tragedies in Jewish history including the destruction of both the First and Second Temples
Despite all the gloom and tragedy described in Lamentations, the rabbis in Eicha Rabbah make a very interesting statement: the Messiah, tradition teaches, is born on Tisha B'Av (Eicha Rabbah 1:51).
Not despite the darkest day. On it.
This idea is not necessarily meant to be taken literally, as though there is a specific infant born each Tisha B'Av somewhere who will one day reveal himself as the Messiah. Rather, it is a teaching about the design of Jewish history itself. It is telling us something we are meant to internalize in how we look at and understand our past and current events: that the seed of redemption is planted precisely inside the moment of destruction. That we rarely see it while we are living through the darkness, but the light is already there, growing quietly, waiting for its moment.
The Pattern Repeats
If we stand back and look at Jewish history, we begin to notice this is not a one-time coincidence. It is a pattern.
Consider the beginning of our national story. The Israelites are enslaved in Egypt, generations of forced labor, infanticide, and despair, with seemingly no way out. Yet it is precisely out of that furnace of suffering that the Exodus emerges, and with it, Mount Sinai: the moment the Jewish people receive the Torah and become a nation with a unique historical mission and destiny. The slavery was not a detour from Jewish destiny. It was, however incomprehensibly, the road to it and an intrinsic part of the whole process.
Centuries later, while the Jews are in Persia, Haman engineers what can only be described as an attempted genocide, a plan to annihilate every Jew, young and old, in a single day, simply because Mordechai, the Jew, would not bow. The Book of Esther reads, for most of its length, like a countdown to catastrophe. But the story does not end with the destruction of the Jewish people. It ends with the destruction of our enemies, with Jewish self-defense and triumph, and, in the aftermath of that victory, with the political and spiritual momentum that allowed the Jewish people to return to their land and complete the rebuilding of the Second Temple. The near annihilation became the prelude to restoration.
Fast forward to July 31st, 1492, the 9th of Av, when the Jews of Spain, the largest and most prosperous Jewish community in the world, are given an ultimatum: convert to Christianity or be expelled. Families are scattered, communities uprooted, an entire golden age extinguished almost overnight. It is one of the great traumas of medieval Jewish history. And three days later, on August 3rd, sailing under the flag of the very kingdom that expelled them, Christopher Columbus stumbles, by accident, searching for a sea route to the Far East, into a hemisphere no European power yet knew existed. It would take centuries for the connection to fully unfold, but the accidental discovery of the Americas eventually opened the door to the creation of the United States: the last great diaspora port of refuge, a nation that would offer Jews something almost unprecedented in two thousand years of wandering, a home where they could build, flourish, and live openly as Jews. The expulsion did not have the last word. It set in motion, unseen and unintended, the conditions for one of the great refuges of Jewish history. The slamming shut of one door in Jewish history led to the opening of another.
And then there is the darkest chapter of them all. The Holocaust: six million Jewish souls, a third of world Jewry, murdered in a genocide of industrial scale and unimaginable horror. No accounting of "silver linings" can or should attempt to explain away that darkness, or suggest it was somehow worth its price. But history records what happened next: the world, confronted with the evidence of what had been allowed to happen, could no longer look away. On November 29, 1947, the United Nations voted to partition Palestine, paving the way for the re-establishment of a Jewish state after two thousand years of exile. Less than six months later, for the first time in two millennia, Jewish sovereignty returned to the Jewish homeland. The blood of the six million did not create justification for the tragedy, nothing could, but it did, in the unfolding of history, play the central role in pushing the world toward allowing what the Jewish people had prayed for in every generation: a return home.
These are just three examples, but there are many more.
A Grandmaster's Game
What do we make of a pattern like this? I like to use the analogy of a grandmaster playing chess. A grandmaster does not simply react to the board move by move. He sees dozens of moves ahead, allowing sacrifices that look, to an untrained eye, like catastrophic blunders (a queen given away, a position seemingly collapsing) because he already knows where the game is heading. What appears to us as chaos, or even defeat, may be a single move within a much larger and wiser strategy, directed by a Higher Power who sees the entire board of history at once, while we can only see the square we are standing on.
But this is not fatalism. Jewish theology insists on something more demanding and more proactive than simply waiting for God to move the pieces for us. All of history is understood as an ongoing interaction between God's infinite power, knowledge, and control, and the genuine free will He grants each of us as individuals, and collectively as a nation, to choose our own path. The destination and the final outcome are never in question. Jewish tradition teaches that we are, collectively, moving toward redemption, toward a world repaired. But the road we take to get there, how long it takes, and how much suffering lines the way, is substantially in our hands. All roads lead to the same final destination; the speed and difficulty of the journey are up to us.
The Challenge Is in the Middle
This is, admittedly, far easier to say from the vantage point of history than to feel in the middle of it. When you are enslaved in Egypt, you do not know Sinai is coming. When Haman's decree is sealed, you do not know the Purim story has a second act. When you are boarding a ship out of Spain with nothing, you cannot conceive of a democracy across an ocean not yet drawn on any map. And when six million are being murdered, there are no words, none, that make sense of what redemption could possibly follow.
That is the real challenge: not to see the silver lining in hindsight, which is easy, but to hold onto the possibility of it while still inside the cloud. Not passively, waiting idly for salvation to descend, but actively, with maximum effort, choosing again and again to move in the right direction, to learn from the past, stay connected, build rather than despair, to hold onto faith and to hold onto responsibility at the same time.
The tradition that the Messiah is born on Tisha B'Av is not a promise that darkness doesn't hurt, or that catastrophe is secretly good. It is a promise that darkness is never the final word. There is always hope. Somewhere inside every tragedy, a seed is already planted. Our task is not to wait for it to grow on its own, but to tend it, with confidence that however hard the road, we will make it to the finish line, and redemption is already on its way.
Subscribe to Posts [Atom]
